In a New York City bar, a drunken Catholic priest named Brian Finn shares the ongoing love triangle involving him, his best friend Jake Schram (a Jewish rabbi), and their childhood friend, Anna Reilly, with the bartender.
Brian, dedicated to his calling as a priest since childhood, shares his parish duties with the elderly Father Havel. Jake, the youngest rabbi at his synagogue, focuses on his work but neglects his romantic life, much to his mother’s chagrin. The pair plans to open an interfaith karaoke community center together, seeking a modern approach to religious services.
Similar Content
Sixteen years later, Anna returns to New York for work, reuniting with Brian and Jake. Anna and Jake start a casual relationship which complicates when they develop mutual feelings, complicated by religious differences. Brian, torn by his own feelings for Anna, contemplates leaving the priesthood.
During a dinner where Ruth, Jake’s mother, reveals knowledge of the secret relationship, tensions rise. Anna reveals her love for Jake, leading Brian to face rejection and internal conflict. The aftermath sees Brian seeking solace in a bar, only to find guidance from a bartender and reaffirm his vows with Father Havel.
As the community center’s opening nears, Brian reconciles with Jake and Anna, urging Jake to confess his feelings before Anna’s departure. Jake’s heartfelt revelation salvages their friendship, with Anna’s surprise reveal of converting to Judaism for him.
The trio’s renewed bond culminates in a celebratory photo, marking a journey of faith, friendship, and love.
Don’t miss out on the emotional rollercoaster of “Keeping the Faith” – watch it now for free and witness the power of faith and love firsthand.